Table I Overview of Product Formulations Tested with Key Moisturizing Ingredients Highlighted INCI Name A B C D Base foundation Base foundation with propylheptyl caprylate Base foundation with moisture blend #1, moisture blend #2, Moringa oleifera seed oil, and propylheptyl caprylate Marketed benchmark Water 53% 50% 42% √ Moisture blend #1 - - 4% Glycerin √ Water √ Urea Sodium PCA √ Trehalose √ Polyquaternium-51 √ Triacetin Sodium hyaluronate √ Moisture Blend #2 - - 2% Ethlyhexyl palmitate Silica dimethyl silylate Butylene glycol √ Sodium hyaluronate Moringa oleifera seed oil - - 2% Propylheptyl caprylate - 3% 3% FOUNDATION PRODUCTS HAVE AN IMPACT ON MOISTURIZATION 361

JOURNAL OF COSMETIC SCIENCE 362 Enrolled panelists were instructed to wash their inner forearms with PURPOSE® Gentle Cleansing Wash (Valeant Consumer Products, Montreal, Canada) once daily for 3 days prior to the study date. Panelists were told to shower 12 h prior to the fi rst and last visit. Additionally, they refrained from using any non-assigned products on their inner fore- arms for the duration of the study. They were required to go to the test facility for 5 consecutive days. MEASUREMENT OF SKIN IMPEDANCE Moisture content in the skin was assessed using a NOVA® DPM 9003 skin impedance meter (NOVA Technology Corporation, Portsmouth, NH). This instrument provides a non-invasive, objective, reproducible method of measurement to quantify biophysical characteristics and relative hydration of the skin. It reports skin impedance in arbitrary units (2). Prior to all measurements, panelists acclimated to controlled environmental conditions with a constant temperature of 19°–22°C and 40–50% relative humidity, for at least 15 min. Five 3 × 3 cm test sites were marked on the forearms using a surgical pen. Within each site, baseline skin impedance measurements were taken on day 1 prior to the fi rst application and again on day 5, 12 h after the last application was washed off. Mois- turization measurements were taken in triplicate at each site. We did not monitor regres- sion of the skin following product application beyond 12 h, as the skin impedance measurement at that time showed suffi cient differentiation among the test products. Also, consumers would generally reapply the product at 12 h after washoff. Table II Other Ingredients in Formulations A, B, and C That Are Not Listed in Table I, Listed Alphabetically by INCI Name Caprylic/Capric triglyceride, Caprylyl glycol, Caprylyl glycol (and) Phenoxyethanol (and) Hexylene glycol, Dimethicone (and) Polysilicone-11 (and) Nylon-12 (and) Silica (and) PEG-10 Dimethicone (and) Polysorbate 40 (and) Isohexadecane (and) Ammonium polyacryloyldimethyl taurate, DMDM Hydantion (and) Iodoproynyl butylcarbamate, Hexyl laurate, Iron oxide (Black), Iron oxide (Red), Iron oxide (Yellow), Isostearic acid, Magnesium aluminum silicate, Mica (and) Titanium dioxide (Orange), Mica (and) Titanium dioxide (Violet), Oleyl erucate, Pentaerythrityl tetra-di-t-butyl hydroxyhydrocinnamate, Silica (and) Hyaluronic acid, Sodium polyacrylate, Synthetic fl uorphlogopite (and) Lauroyl lysine, Titanium dioxide, Vegetable oil (and) Glycerin (and) Lauryl glucoside (and) Polyglycerl-2-dipolyhydroxystearate Table III Other Ingredients in Formulation D That Are Not Listed in Table I, Listed Alphabetically by INCI Name 1,2-Hexanediol, Aloe barbadensis leaf extract, Argania spinosa kernel oil, Boron nitride, C12-15 Alkyl benzoate, Caprylic/Capric triglyceride, Caprylyl glycol, Cellulose gum, Ceteth-25, Cetyl alcohol, Cetyl ethylhexanoate, Disodium EDTA, Ethylhexyl methoxycinnamate, Glyceryl stearate, Helianthus annuus (Sunfl ower) seed oil, Hexapeptide-3, Iron oxide (Black), Iron oxide (Red), Iron oxide (Yellow), Isopropyl lanolate, Linoleic acid, Linolenic acid, Magnesium aluminum silicate, Oleth-25, PEG-26-PPG-30 Phosphate, Persea gratissima (Avocodo) oil, Polyhydroxystearic acid, Proplyene glycol isostearate, Propylene glycol, Propylene glycol stearate, Sodium dehydroacetate, Squalane, Titanium dioxide, Tocopherol, Triethanolamine, Tripeptide-3