510 JOURNAL OF THE SOCIETY OF COSMETIC CHEMISTS due to the rising demands for the scientific documentation of advertising claims, has interest been focused on the development of reliable quantitative measurements for product efficacy on human hair and skin. We have found electron microscopy, and in particular, scanning electron microscopy (SEM) to be a powerful tool for scientifically documenting the effects of materials applied to human hair and skin. The transmission elec- tron microscope (TEM) also has its place, but since SEM is basically a sur- face (topographical) tool, and since studies of products on hair and skin in- volve surfaces (protein deposits on the outside of a hair shaft skin roughness is a surface phenomonen), the SEM is generally the instrument of choice. The SEM and TEM, rather than "competing" with each other, are actually complementary, and most important studies ultimately involve the use of both. The present work is not the first application of SEM for cosmetic studies. In fact, as early as the 1940s (1, 2) various methods of replicating the outer cuticle structure of hair were devised through the use of platinum and carbon techniques. The SEM, which really started to develop as a scientific tool in the late 19fi0s, was quickly utilized to examine human hair, and Wolfram and Lindemann (3) published a study of the structure and morphology of hair. Further studies have demonstrated yet additional information on hair (4, 5) and, more recently, some very novel studies have been published on the elucidation of the actual structure of the cuticle (fi). One of the most in- ventire approaches was for the study of porosity within human hair (7), which describes a method for the polymerization of methacrylate toohomer in situ. within the holes or pores that exist within the hair structure. The hair is then degraded away, leaving the now "plastic pores" (or "ghosts") avail- able for collection and characterization by SEM. A method for demonstrating the repair of damaged hair and a classification scheme for identifying and quantitating different types of damage has now been reported by DiBianca (8). This latter method was used to substantiate the claim that a hair care product can repair damaged hair. Although the amount that is now known and published about human hair is substantial, by comparison very little SEM and/or TEM work has been published about human skin. Virtually no SEM or TEM studies have been published that demonstrate the effects or efficacy of specific products on the stratum eorneum. This absence of data is not for lack of interest, but because of the enormous experimental difficulties encountered with skin studies. These difficulties have, therefore, severely limited the application of SEM and/or TEM techniques to the skin area. For TEM studies, a biopsy sample must be (1) "fixed" (hardened to keep it from degrading) (2) embedded (so it can be sectioned) (3) sectioned (4) "stained" to bring out contrast and (5) photographed within the high vacuum of the electron microscope. Put quite simply, the changes brought about by the fixing, embedding, and staining are enormous as compared to
SCANNING ELECTRON MICROSCOPY 511 the relatively subtle changes brought about by the application of a cosmetic product. In fact, even an oily material applied to the surface of a biopsy sam- ple will tend to diffuse away into the embedding material and not remain on the sample. Hence, for all of these reasons, SEM tends to be the tool of choice for most skin studies. Our first SEM studies on human skin did involve biopsy samples, both ani- mal as well as human. We learned quite quickly that the severe dehydration effects of the ultra high vacuum within the SEM left the sample so severely shrunken, distorted, and changed that any relationship between reality and what we were seeing would have certainly been fortuitous. Even some of the newer and more sophisticated methods of sample preparation, such as critical point drying or freeze drying, were not particularly better. Consequently, we have concentrated virtually all of our efforts toward procedures employing skin replicas, which have the advantage that we cannot only characterize by SEM the in vivo state of an area of stratum corncure, but we can also follow the same identical area in the micrographs as a function of time, in a sense, like a high magnification form of time lapse photography. In this way, 'we can follow the effects of a product as a function of time, and evaluate the ef- ficacy of this product relative to a control. Surely, we •vere not the first to make replicas of human skin. Facq (9, 10) and Berstein (11, 12) learned back in the late 1960s that normal silicone resin, either of the RTV-11 type* or even the impression materials used in dentistry, would make "acceptable" (relatively free of artifacts) replicas of the top surface of the skin (and, hence, also the top surface of the stratum comeurn). Once having obtained the "impression" or "negative" as we prefer to call it, the negative is itself replicated, yielding a "positive" replica of the skin surface. There was also a problem with artifacts in the replicas, such as air bubbles, which tended to limit, in certain respects, the utility of these original efforts. Unfortunately, artifacts were not the only drawbacks t ø the methods origi- nally used. First, was the criticism that too small an area was being studied how was it known that this small area was indeed representative of that area of stratum corncure as a whole? In addition, the enormous heterogeneities present from point to point on the stratum corncure were such that one could almost prove or disprove anything by a careful selection of the area. Our approach was to develop a procedure that would enable us to do the following. 1. produce high resolution (virtually) artifact-free negative replicas 2. convert the negative replicas to high resolution positive replicas *General Electric Company, Wateroeord, N.Y. 12188.
Purchased for the exclusive use of nofirst nolast (unknown) From: SCC Media Library & Resource Center (library.scconline.org)


































































