618 JOURNAL OF COSMETIC SCIENCE
while marginal growth is observed for 9 ppm of peptide as expected. The similarity of the
second part of the curves indicates that cells regained growth potential identical to the one
observed for the control. Thus, the peptide possesses an inhibitory effect when in contact
with C. acnes, but this effect is lifted in its absence.
Effect of pKTSKS on C. acnes biofilm formation. Because of inhibitory effect of pKTSKS
has on C. acnes growth, we decided to investigate its impact in biofilm. Indeed, C. acnes
biofilms have a significant impact on acne development. Biofilm form makes C. acnes
more resistant and triggers an important inflammatory response.11–14 We therefore tested
the effect of pKTSKS on C. acnes biofilm by focusing on two steps: adhesion and biofilm
formation. C. acnes adhesion was evaluated on the surface of plastic plates after crystal
violet extraction. For the solvent (DMSO), OD
600nm was 2.74 ± 0.12 units, the presence
of pKTSKS almost completely reduced this bacterial adhesion by 98% and 99% after
72 hours at 6 and 12 ppm respectively (Figure 4). Regarding biofilm formation, for solvent,
OD
600nm was 2.22 ± 0.34 after 72 hours. The presence of pKTSKS strongly prevented
this biofilm formation by C. acnes for 6 and 12 ppm (–97% and –98% respectively both
p 0.01). DMSO itself had only a slight effect on biofilm adhesion assay: +18.1% compared
to untreated control, (p 0.05) and no effect on biofilm formation (–4.3%, ns). Effect of
DMSO on biofilm adhesion is marginal when compared to effect of the peptide. Prevention
of C. acnes adhesion and of biofilm formation by pKTSKS both reduce C. acnes ability to
reach its quorum and would avoid a quorum sensing effect.
Growth of S. epidermidis with pKTSKS. S. epidermidis is one of the most abundant commensal
microorganisms on human skin. While it serves as repellent for its pathogenic cousin,
S. aureus, it can also control the excessive development of C. acnes.26 It is therefore of interest
to evaluate whether pKTSKS could affect S. epidermidis growth. S. epidermidis was seeded
at 7 × 107 CFU/mL in TSY medium. Its growth was monitored over time. Neither 0.1%
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
Biofilm Biofilm dhesion a formag415on
Axis Title
Effect of pKTSKS on C. acnes biofilm adhesion and
formag415on
Untreated control DMSO pKTSKS 6ppm pKTSKS 12ppm
Figure 4. Evaluation of the effect of pKTSKS on C. acnes biofilm adhesion (left) and formation (right) after
72 h treatment with solvent (DMSO) or pKTSKS (6 ppm and 12 ppm). The biofilm was quantified using the
crystal violet staining method. The amount of crystal violet retained by the biofilm was then measured by
assessing the optical density at 600 nm (OD600).
OD
600nm
619 Pentapeptide to Control Acne
DMSO nor pKTSKS (Figure 5) affected S. epidermidis growth. These results can be compared
with those displayed in Figure 2 to highlight the role of pKTSKS on bacterial growth.
Furthermore, S. epidermidis abundance in the microbiota of volunteers was also measured
during the clinical trial described above. S. epidermidis population was not modified by
pKTSKS in vivo: +15.4% (p =0.36). These data confirm that pKTSKS inhibits C. acnes
without modulating S. epidermidis growth.
EFFECT OF PKTSKS ON EPIDERMIS
Skin barrier functions. The epidermal barrier is one of the keystones of our body’s protection.
A good barrier preserves skin hydration and provides a healthy substrate for resident
microbiota. It requires an epidermis whose keratinocytes are fully differentiated. Incomplete
keratinocytes differentiation can lead to thinning of the stratum corneum and to a greater
penetration of bacterial allergens favoring proinflammatory mechanisms. Figure 6 and
Table I show the positive effect of pentapeptide pKTSKS on epidermal differentiation.
Whereas epidermis thickness is moderately modified (−6%), stratum corneum thickness
increases by 186% (p 0.01 versus control gel).
1.3
1.35
1.4
1.45
1.5
1.55
1.6
30h 20h
Time (h)
Effect of pKTSKS on S. epidermidis growth
Solvent control pKTSKS 6ppm pKTSKS 9ppm pKTSKS 12ppm
Figure 5. Effect of pKTSKS on S. epidermidis growth kinetic over time (n =7). Turbidity measurements
(OD600nm) on S. epidermidis, to evaluate effect of pKTSKS on S. epidermidis growth after 20 h and 30 h of
treatment with pKTSKS.
Figure 6. Effect of pKTSKS (9 ppm) on Stratum Corneum Thickness in LSE. The thickness of the stratum
corneum was measured in H&E-stained sections, as indicated by white bars (n =4). LSE were topically treated
with pKTSKS or control for 48 h, embedded in freezing media, and sectioned into 5–7 µm slices for analysis.
OD
600nm
Previous Page Next Page